Tyler man accused of killing girlfriend, setting house on fire indicted for capital murder

Published 5:35 am Saturday, April 5, 2025

A Tyler man accused of killing his girlfriend by throwing gasoline on her and setting her house on fire is now facing a capital murder charge.

Gregory Bargaineer, 67, was arrested Nov. 18 after turning himself in for the death of Marilyn Janis McEachin, who was found in the back of her house on Shady Trail Drive that same morning. He was initially charged with murder and arson.

On Jan. 30, a grand jury handed down an indictment for capital murder by terror threat/other felony, meaning the alleged murder was committed while the suspect was committing another felony.

Read more from our news partners at CBS19.